Social media customers have criticised the newest episode of And Simply Like That for cultural misappropriation and perpetuating south Asian stereotypes.
The most recent episode of the Intercourse and the Metropolis reboot, titled Diwali, sees protagonist Carrie Bradshaw accompany her new buddy, Seema Patel, on a purchasing journey to purchase an outfit for the competition.
Diwali, also called the Pageant of Lights, is likely one of the main non secular celebrations for Hindus, Sikhs and Jains.
Bradshaw additionally meets Patel’s dad and mom, who query her about their daughter’s made-up boyfriend – an affront to cease them badgering Patel about getting married.
Twitter customers shortly identified a number of of the episode’s shortfalls.
Many have been in disbelief that Bradshaw’s character had little information of Diwali and wanted to be educated concerning the competition by Patel.
“This present options the final white lady in New Yok who doesn’t know what Diwali is,” one consumer mentioned.
One other wrote: “Seema goes to elucidate Diwali to Carrie as if there should not a gazillion Desis residing in New York Metropolis.”
On their purchasing journey to search out Diwali outfits, Patel and Bradshaw enter a “sari store” which is filled with custom south Asian lehengas.
A lehenga, which is available in many various kinds, is an ankle-length skirt which will be worn with an extended, quick or cropped shirt.
A sari is an extended piece of fabric which is wrapped over a shirt, throughout the shoulders, across the waist and over the legs.
The phrase “lehenga” isn’t utilized by both of the characters, despite the fact that Bradshaw later attends the Diwali get together carrying a full-skirted Falguni Shane lehenga and choli (a cropped shirt) within the type “Peacock”.
“So, they’re going ‘sari’ purchasing in a retailer that solely has lehengas on the racks?” one consumer wrote.
“Diwali get together scene and Carrie is certainly not carrying a sari. She is carrying a lehnga that’s attractive however an excessive amount of for this small get together,” they added.
One other mentioned: “Placing Carrie in a lehenga and calling it cultural appreciation is okay however calling the lehenga a sari is unforgivable.”
The episode additionally performs out a stereotype generally related to south Asian households – that many dad and mom of the diaspora are fixated on marriage.
Vogue Indiaauthor Arushi Sinha described the scene the place Patel’s dad and mom query Bradshaw about their daughter’s boyfriend as “stale and badly thought-out”.
“In case you’re solely going to point out a slender slice of an Indian character’s life, it’s in all probability not a good suggestion to lean so closely into mass-produced stereotypes that don’t add depth or dimension to the characters in query,” Sinha wrote.
One Twitter consumer described the stereotype as outdated and clichéd.
“Can we get any extra clichéd? Belief me, dad and mom of that diaspora from the Sixties would actually not care about getting Seema hitched. And positively, not at this level,” they mentioned.
Kaynak: briturkish.com